This story stars my Grandpa Eli Maghe, my mom’s dad, who was hands-down the funniest, crankiest, most stubborn old coot you’d ever meet. And trust me, he earned that title on one epic day at Tenkiller Ferry Lake.
Grandpa Maghe loved fishing more than anything. Didn’t matter that he wasn’t exactly reeling in trophies every time—he just loved being out on the water, puffing on his pipe, telling corny jokes, and teasing me about everything from my worm-baiting skills to my “city boy” sneakers. He was skinny as a rail, with a permanent twinkle in his eye and a grin that said he was always up to something. I thought he was the smartest man alive, especially when it came to fish. If Grandpa said it, it was gospel.

One perfect summer weekend, it was just us three fellas: me, my dad, and Grandpa, heading out in his no-frills 16-foot aluminum boat. Nothing fancy—no shiny gadgets or comfy seats, just benches, a growly old 40-horse Evinrude motor that sounded like an angry lawnmower, and a pile of fishing rods. We launched at the ramp on a morning where the lake was smooth as glass, the sun shining bright, and the water that deep, clear blue you get at Tenkiller (well, clear for Oklahoma, anyway).
We motored into a quiet cove, dropped anchor, and cast our lines. For about an hour, it was peaceful—birds chirping, bobbers bobbing, Grandpa puffing his pipe and grumbling about “slow bite days.” Then… WHAM! Grandpa’s rod bent like a horseshoe. “I got a monster!” he hollered, eyes lighting up like Christmas. Whatever was on the other end was huge—a giant bass, no doubt about it. That fish took us on a wild ride, dragging our little boat all over the cove like we were on a rodeo bull.
Grandpa fought it hard, reeling and yelling instructions at the fish (as if it could hear him). But suddenly, the line went dead stiff. No more fight. Grandpa tugged and pulled, his face turning redder than a tomato. “That rascal’s wedged himself under a rock!” he declared. How did he know? Beats me—I was only 8—but Grandpa was a fishing genius in my book, so I nodded like it made perfect sense.
He fumed and fussed, yanking on that line till I thought the rod would snap. No way was he cutting it loose. “Ain’t losing this one,” he muttered. Then, to my total shock (picture my jaw hitting the boat floor), Grandpa stands up, starts stripping off his shirt, pants, shoes—everything—until he’s standing there in nothing but his bright white tighty-whities!
Yep, you heard that right. My skinny old grandpa, pipe clenched in his teeth, in his bright white cotton underwear and pale-white wrinkled skin, on the edge of the boat. Other fishermen were out there in the distance, probably sipping coffee and minding their own business. And Grandpa? He gives us a determined nod, like he’s about to win a gold medal, and DIVES IN HEADFIRST! Splashes everywhere!
I was frozen. Couldn’t even blink. Dad just shook his head, half-laughing. Down Grandpa went into that deep, cool water—40 feet deep, easy. It was clear enough to see him kicking like a frog for the first 15 feet or so, then… poof, gone into the blue haze.
We waited. And waited. Felt like forever. Finally, he pops up, sputtering water, coughing, and letting out a string of words I’m pretty sure weren’t in the Bible. “Dang fish is stubborn!” he gasps. Catches his breath… and down he goes again!
This happened over and over—dive after dive, like Grandpa was part submarine. Each time he’d surface emptier-handed than the last, madder than a wet hen, but twice as determined. Me? I was torn between being terrified he’d never come back up and trying not to giggle at the sight of my underwear-clad grandpa battling an invisible fish monster.
In the end, that big bass won the day. Grandpa never freed the line, never hauled in his prize. Dad finally helped haul the soaked, shivering, still-grumbling old man back into the boat without flipping us all overboard. We motored home without that trophy fish, but who cared? I’d witnessed the greatest show on the lake: Grandpa Eli Maghe, in his tighty-whities, declaring war on a bass that probably still tells the story to its grandfish today.
If that doesn’t prove Grandpa Maghe was one of a kind—brave, bullheaded, and hilarious all at once—I don’t know what does. He didn’t catch the fish, but he sure caught a memory that’ll last forever. And honestly? That’s the best catch of all.
Leave a Reply